Please click on the poster thumbnail above to enlarge the image.
Audio Presentation
Link will open in a new tab.
Chameleon Logic: Extractive Informality, Regulatory Pressure, and the Adaptive Governance of Artisanal and Small -Scale Mining in Ghana
Abstract:
Why do repeated attempts to suppress, formalize, or regulate artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM)—a low-tech, labor-intensive form of mineral extraction practiced in more than eighty countries—so often produce adaptation rather than transformation? In Ghana, more than three decades of legal reform, military crackdowns, and formalization programs have left an estimated 70–80% of ASM informal, and the sector's share of national gold output peaked at 43% in 2018, the year of a nationwide ban. This paper introduces "Chameleon Logic" to explain this persistence: the structurally produced mechanism through which extractive informality reconfigures its form, visibility, and spatial organization under regulatory pressure, reproducing itself through intervention rather than despite it. Drawing on 73 in-depth interviews, five focus groups, and observations at twelve mining sites, we compare two contrasting districts: Amansie South, shaped by militarized enforcement, and Ellembelle, where Ghana's flagship cooperative formalization program was first piloted. Under enforcement, informality reorganizes through intelligence networks, hide-and-return practices, night mining, political patronage, and renegotiated customary land access. Under formalization, it reorganizes through selective legibility, the continued authority of chiefs, and sponsorship arrangements that establish the distribution of value before extraction begins. We theorize these dynamics across four dimensions: a frontier operating system, regulated improvisation, a value-capture interface, and governed illegibility. Secondary evidence from Zimbabwe and Peru suggests the mechanism travels beyond Ghana. We argue that informality is a governance formation rather than a regulatory deficit and that effective interventions must engage the relational infrastructures that already organize extraction.
Keywords: Artisanal and small-scale mining, chameleon logic, extractive informality, frontier governance, political ecology, Ghana
Authors:
SEIBA ISSIFU, THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY; Submitting Author / Primary Presenter
SEIBA D WOODWORTH, THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY; Co-Author (this author will not present)
Victoria Anisomyansah, University of Cape Coast; Co-Author (this author will not present)
, ;
, {SubmissionForm.presentersAuthors/affiliation#4};
, ;
, ;
, ;
, ;
, ;
Chameleon Logic: Extractive Informality, Regulatory Pressure, and the Adaptive Governance of Artisanal and Small -Scale Mining in Ghana
Category
Paper Abstract
Description
This abstract is part of the session: Labor & Social Reproduction